7 days V2
Fire Truck Union Contract V3
Surge in Property Taxes V3
Fire Union Tax Increase V2
AT-A-GLANCE: THE COST TO BONITA SPRINGS TAXPAYERS
- The Schedule Handout: Moving from a 24/48 shift (1 day on, 2 days off) to a 24/72 shift (1 day on, 3 days off)—meaning firefighters work roughly 7.5 days per month.
- The Hiring Bloat: Forces the district to hire 34 new personnel (32 firefighters and 2 Battalion Chiefs) just to cover the extra days off.
- The Direct Tax Hit: Adds $7.18 Million in recurring annual payroll and benefits—forcing a +19.5% net property tax increase on Bonita Springs homeowners and businesses.
- The Operational Reality: Fewer than 0.25% of district emergency calls are actual structural fires in a community built largely of modern concrete construction.
I. The 24/72 Shift Scheme: Why One Extra Day Off Costs $7.18 Million
Covering a fire station 24 hours a day, 7 days a week under a standard ‘1 day on, 2 days off’ schedule requires three rotating shifts (A, B, and C). Moving to a ‘1 day on, 3 days off’ schedule (24/72) requires adding an entire fourth shift line (D-Shift)—automatically inflating operational staffing requirements by roughly 33% without adding a single new fire station or rescue truck.
Union-Backed Agenda: Fire Commissioner candidate/elect Larry Kosilla has championed this union-backed shift expansion. Enacting it forces Bonita Springs taxpayers to fund 34 brand-new full-time positions—32 firefighters and 2 Battalion Chiefs—at an annual recurring cost of $7.18 Million. That permanent payroll explosion translates directly into a +19.5% net property tax increase on local families and businesses, even though fewer than a quarter of one percent of local callouts involve actual structural fires.

II. Standalone Pension Abuses & Artificial Final-Year Salary Spiking
- 52.5% Richer Than County and State EMS & State Firefighters: Under the Florida Retirement System (FRS) Special Risk class, Lee County EMS paramedics and State of Florida firefighters receive a 3.0% annual benefit multiplier and a 4.0% DROP interest rate. Bonita Springs’ standalone plan forces property taxpayers to guarantee a 3.58% multiplier for senior staff and a fixed 6.5% annual DROP interest return—handing out nearly $19,000 a year in extra interest bonuses on a single $750,000 DROP balance.
- Artificial Leave-Bank Spiking (Prohibited Under FRS): Working roughly 7 to 10 shifts a month allows personnel to accumulate massive banks of unused sick, vacation, and holiday time. While FRS strictly caps how much unused leave can be included in a member’s final average compensation, Bonita Springs’ standalone rules allow retirees to dump banked days straight into their final year’s salary—artificially spiking their lifetime pension calculation right at the finish line.
- Zero Employee Skin in the Game: Over 85% of private-sector workers do not receive a defined-benefit pension bonus at all. Yet Bonita Springs taxpayers pay hundreds of thousands of dollars annually for private pension board attorneys, private actuaries (Foster & Foster), and money managers charging 40–60 basis points (compared to just 7 basis points at the Florida State Board of Administration) without requiring firefighters to contribute the standard 3% employee salary contribution.

III. Double Taxation: The Mandatory 1.85% Property Insurance Tax Surcharge
In addition to rising ad valorem property tax bills, local homeowners and commercial business owners are hit with a mandatory 1.85% state excise tax (authorized under Florida Statutes Chapter 175) tacked directly onto their property insurance policies. Across Lee County’s independent fire districts, this hidden surcharge extracts over $12.5 Million every year from property policyholders—channeling more than $5.7 Million annually above statutory baselines straight into supplemental firefighter ‘Share Account’ bonus payouts.

IV. The Solution: Taxpayer Action Plan
- Reject the 24/72 Shift Expansion: Demand that the Bonita Springs Fire Commission block any move from 2 days off to 3 days off that forces the hiring of 34 new staff or triggers a +19.5% property tax increase.
- Consolidate Lee County’s 17 Independent Fire Districts: Merge the 17 separate fire kingdoms into ONE unified countywide fire district under Lee County Government—saving taxpayers up to $23 Million in operating costs and $16 Million in pension administration overhead every year.
- Enforce FRS Parity & 3% Employee Contributions: Require standalone pension participants to contribute at least 3% of their salaries toward their own retirement, ban final-year leave spiking, and align benefit multipliers with Lee County EMS paramedics.

Contact: Dave Jaye, Researcher | 586-488-5177 | dave.jaye55@gmail.com
If you know of other taxpayer-abusive and wasteful TrippleDipper programs, please contact us and join our email list to be notified of important news and new reports.
Join our mailing list!





