BONITA
SPRINGS

TAXPAYER ABUSE IN BONITA SPRINGS: FIRE UNION PUSHES 3 DAYS OFF FOR EVERY 1 DAY WORKED—TRIGGERING A $7.18 MILLION PAYROLL EXPLOSION & 19.5% PROPERTY TAX HIKE

7 days V2

Fire Truck Union Contract V3

Surge in Property Taxes V3

Fire Union Tax Increase V2

AT-A-GLANCE: THE COST TO BONITA SPRINGS TAXPAYERS

  • The Schedule Handout: Moving from a 24/48 shift (1 day on, 2 days off) to a 24/72 shift (1 day on, 3 days off)—meaning firefighters work roughly 7.5 days per month.
  • The Hiring Bloat: Forces the district to hire 34 new personnel (32 firefighters and 2 Battalion Chiefs) just to cover the extra days off.
  • The Direct Tax Hit: Adds $7.18 Million in recurring annual payroll and benefits—forcing a +19.5% net property tax increase on Bonita Springs homeowners and businesses.
  • The Operational Reality: Fewer than 0.25% of district emergency calls are actual structural fires in a community built largely of modern concrete construction.

I. The 24/72 Shift Scheme: Why One Extra Day Off Costs $7.18 Million

Covering a fire station 24 hours a day, 7 days a week under a standard ‘1 day on, 2 days off’ schedule requires three rotating shifts (A, B, and C). Moving to a ‘1 day on, 3 days off’ schedule (24/72) requires adding an entire fourth shift line (D-Shift)—automatically inflating operational staffing requirements by roughly 33% without adding a single new fire station or rescue truck.

Union-Backed Agenda: Fire Commissioner candidate/elect Larry Kosilla has championed this union-backed shift expansion. Enacting it forces Bonita Springs taxpayers to fund 34 brand-new full-time positions—32 firefighters and 2 Battalion Chiefs—at an annual recurring cost of $7.18 Million. That permanent payroll explosion translates directly into a +19.5% net property tax increase on local families and businesses, even though fewer than a quarter of one percent of local callouts involve actual structural fires.

II. Standalone Pension Abuses & Artificial Final-Year Salary Spiking

  • 52.5% Richer Than County and State EMS & State Firefighters: Under the Florida Retirement System (FRS) Special Risk class, Lee County EMS paramedics and State of Florida firefighters receive a 3.0% annual benefit multiplier and a 4.0% DROP interest rate. Bonita Springs’ standalone plan forces property taxpayers to guarantee a 3.58% multiplier for senior staff and a fixed 6.5% annual DROP interest return—handing out nearly $19,000 a year in extra interest bonuses on a single $750,000 DROP balance.
  • Artificial Leave-Bank Spiking (Prohibited Under FRS): Working roughly 7 to 10 shifts a month allows personnel to accumulate massive banks of unused sick, vacation, and holiday time. While FRS strictly caps how much unused leave can be included in a member’s final average compensation, Bonita Springs’ standalone rules allow retirees to dump banked days straight into their final year’s salary—artificially spiking their lifetime pension calculation right at the finish line.
  • Zero Employee Skin in the Game: Over 85% of private-sector workers do not receive a defined-benefit pension bonus at all. Yet Bonita Springs taxpayers pay hundreds of thousands of dollars annually for private pension board attorneys, private actuaries (Foster & Foster), and money managers charging 40–60 basis points (compared to just 7 basis points at the Florida State Board of Administration) without requiring firefighters to contribute the standard 3% employee salary contribution.

III. Double Taxation: The Mandatory 1.85% Property Insurance Tax Surcharge

In addition to rising ad valorem property tax bills, local homeowners and commercial business owners are hit with a mandatory 1.85% state excise tax (authorized under Florida Statutes Chapter 175) tacked directly onto their property insurance policies. Across Lee County’s independent fire districts, this hidden surcharge extracts over $12.5 Million every year from property policyholders—channeling more than $5.7 Million annually above statutory baselines straight into supplemental firefighter ‘Share Account’ bonus payouts.

IV. The Solution: Taxpayer Action Plan

  1. Reject the 24/72 Shift Expansion: Demand that the Bonita Springs Fire Commission block any move from 2 days off to 3 days off that forces the hiring of 34 new staff or triggers a +19.5% property tax increase.
  2. Consolidate Lee County’s 17 Independent Fire Districts: Merge the 17 separate fire kingdoms into ONE unified countywide fire district under Lee County Government—saving taxpayers up to $23 Million in operating costs and $16 Million in pension administration overhead every year.
  3. Enforce FRS Parity & 3% Employee Contributions: Require standalone pension participants to contribute at least 3% of their salaries toward their own retirement, ban final-year leave spiking, and align benefit multipliers with Lee County EMS paramedics.

Contact: Dave Jaye, Researcher | 586-488-5177 | dave.jaye55@gmail.com

If you know of other taxpayer-abusive and wasteful TrippleDipper programs, please contact us and join our email list to be notified of important news and new reports.

Join our mailing list!

Be among the first to receive our latest reports and findings. Sign up now.